The big news in Platteville is this: First National Bank got a new sign that’s red and fancy instead of their former green one.
Oh, yeah, and we’re getting a Super Wal-Mart.
Apparently there is a faction of people in this country who are opposed to not only the building of Wal-Mart in Platteville but also the idea of Wal-Mart in general. I went to the city council meeting last night to cover it for the Exponent and there were over 50 people in the audience, something I can only assume that is unheard of at Platteville city council meetings. Half seemed top be in favor of the proposed public improvement agreement that would allow the building of a Super Wal-Mart just off Highway 151. The development includes a really big Wal-Mart building and parking lot, a strip mall right next door and residential zoning for both single family and multiple resident housing (read: apartments and houses).
One of the opponents of the plan was heard to say “I am afraid of what Wal-Mart will do to this community.” Exqueeze me? Did I miss something here? I know I’m not all up on my current events, but last time I checked Wal-Mart was not in the business of weapon-making and bone-crushing. Are they suddenly going to start raping our wives and pillaging our children? Have we somehow voted to allow some sort of death factory to build just outside our wonderfully pure and clean community? I mean come on people! It’s not as if we’ve allowed the French in…
But I guess there is something to be said for fear of Wal-Mart. How couldn’t we hate someone or something that is the physical embodiment of the American capitalist system? I can’t stand it when people take the same economic system that has helped MY business grow and perfect it to the point that they are an un-stoppable corporate machine. Also, its not as if Wal-Mart means certain death for Platteville. One thing that the audience apparently needed to be reminded of was that Platteville, in fact, already has a Wal-Mart on it’s soil. The economic impact is already there. Besides, to paraphrase from Chris’s dad (the lawyer representing the development) I’m still going to shop at all the other stores in town and any time people come into Platteville to spend their money is a good thing for Platteville.
Here’s a question for those who don’t want to feed the Wal-Mart beast: do you drink Coke? Pepsi? Shop at Amazon.com? Listen to the radio? Buy brand-name clothing items? Shop at the current Platteville Wal-Mart? Watch TV? Get your news from some sort of major news source? Go to school? Plan on dying? Own a computer? If they answered yes to any of these things they should realize that they are already forking over their cash and commitment to corporate giants. It was great to see one of the opponents leave the meeting to go get a Diet Coke and a pack of Lays potato chips. I almost took a picture.
What irks me most is that this Wal-Mart dilemma is taking the focus off the true global scourge: Oprah. Wal-Mart brought us the magic of the $5.50 DVD bin and continually discounted oatmeal creampies. Oprah brought us Dr. Phil and the idea that we can only read officially sanctioned Oprah literature. It seems to me that, while Wal-Mart is an example of the American ideals of freedom and low, low prices Oprah exemplifies somme sort of big-brother communist state where all our information is controlled by one very wealthy and obnoxious person.
Down with Oprah, up with savings!
Posted by Brandon O at March 9, 2005 9:54 AMYeah, but for an old lady, Oprah is kinda hot....
But I do agree - we're (assuming we means Pville citizens) hoping to bolster our economy through any means possible, right? And what does that mean? More business, brought to you by businesses (ie: WalMart). Chris's dad does have a good point - if I want a cup of good coffee, I'd go to Badger Bros - if I want a good bike, off to Momentum. WalMart doesn't have these things. And what about those people who say "Oh, Wally World (Super) will ruin the small businesses..." So why don't they just offer better deals or join with the corporate whore and suck on her proverbial tit? They're in it for the profit too bucko
Still think Oprah's not too bad looking though
That and I refuse to read anything off of her crappy books list... After The Heart is a Lonely Hunter I cannot forgive her.
Posted by: thomas at March 9, 2005 10:19 AMJust for fun, Lays and Diet Coke are made from corporate giants wo are in feirce competition with one another, and further for your infotainment I am now working for another corporate giant that competes with arguably the biggest corporate giant in the world.
Posted by: Sam at March 9, 2005 10:44 AMSpeaking of Steve Jobs, am I the only one who is loving this free iTunes promotion with Pepsi? I say, about corporations that is, that they should be allowed to opperate within the government restrictions that they are required to opperate within. I have nothing against them inherantly. I'd much rather buy used than new anyway. Also, the people hoping for the economic impact study (which was turned down by the council because it would not really determine anything concretely anyway) rallied around their flag of business example: Mr. Brodbeck of Dicks supermarket, the store that has a controlling monopoly on the Platteville grocery market. He said he didn't do an ec.imp.study for his stores when he opened them but instead looked for how they could gain controll of the market. If you are going to allow any businesses to come in to town unopposed you have to let all come in unopposed.
Posted by: brandon o at March 9, 2005 12:20 PMDear Americans, When you shop do you look for the highest quality goods for the lowest possible price? Then it should come to no surprise to you that Walmart could take over this country. As long as you have standards, Walmart will continue to do business. Are they evil? Yes. Can you avoid it? Probably not.
Posted by: John at March 9, 2005 2:58 PMThere was a comercial on just a minute ago on Fox News (John) and there was a Wal-Mart commercial intended only to improve Wal-Mart's image as a healthy addition to any town.
Now, I really don't have anything against Wal-Mart. They essentially filled a good niche better than any other company out there and then as it got bigger, just used it's leverage like all get out to get better deals from producers and sell the crap out of it. There are still competitors out there, like K-Mart+Sears, Target, Krogers, Shop-Ko and Meyers.
I DO agree with Brandon however. It's one thing to monopolize a market because you're just being way more competitive and well run than all your competitors. It's quite another thing to monopolize the market place of ideas like Oprah. (Although she may be dominating a single but huge demographic)
Posted by: Sam at March 9, 2005 6:25 PMGood point
I may be a bit biased, but it's the same way with the military. The raging liberals (ie: English professors) rant and rave that the military is too big, too powerful, and much to sexy for their own good. But would they trade the protection and might that the US military (me) offers? No way. Without us, they wouldn't know what to do. Heck - Tajikistan would take us over just so they could produce more textiles.
Hooah
Posted by: thomas at March 9, 2005 6:26 PMYou are missing the point about what Wal-Mart does to communitites and how they accomplish it. Wal-Mart offers the cheapest prices around, granted, but, they do it by using cheap labor overseas (they are not alone in this I agree) and by not treating their employees well. The Wal-Mart corporate mentality is "why should we pay employees well and give them benefits, there is welfare/Medicaid for that". Also, who do you think you are fooling, to say you will continue going to the same stores you currently shop at. If you are in Wal-Mart and need hamburger for dinner, are you going to stop at Dicks on the way home, or just buy it while you are there? Are you going to do "regular shopping" at Wal-Mart then drive across the street to shop at Aldi's? I live in Madison, and do not shop at Wal-Mart.
Posted by: Linda at March 9, 2005 8:58 PMIf I stop shopping at Dicks it will be because they set their prices exorbitantly high on some items because they control the food market in this town and not because of convenience. I shop for price. If I can get something cheaper I will get it cheaper. Also, I think an addition of Wal-Mart to Platteville is a good idea because I know of a whole lot of students who are in need of a job right now or they will have to stop going to school for lack of money. Wal-Mart is a job and with the couple of thousand new students coming to P-ville from the Tri State initiative and they need jobs too. My thought is this: yes they should provide all those bennefits to their upper management, but I don't get any bennefits for working at the movie theater. I have little to no sympathy for people who strive for nothing higher in life than a Wal-Mart career. Use that cash earned as a part-timer and go to school for something better.
Posted by: brandon o at March 10, 2005 11:06 AM"I live in Madison, and do not shop at Wal-Mart."
That's almost like saying, "I live in the Vatican and I go to Mass."
Posted by: Sam at March 10, 2005 4:09 PMBig business is a part of life. Sam Waldon set out to make a store, as has been stated several times, that supplies a decent product at a reasonable value. And it grew from there because that's what the people want. Sure it changes a community, but the only reason that it does is because people CHOOSE to shop there - and it subsequently grows in popularity. Why blame the corporation for what we as consumers CHOOSE (there's that word again) to do? You don't blame the beer - it's the alcoholic who takes a drink (ie: Brandon Otte), right?
Am I right or am I right.
Posted by: thomas at March 10, 2005 6:09 PMdude i love the pepsi itunes thing i thought it was great!
Posted by: angie at March 30, 2005 9:47 PMI used to be an off campus student at UWP. The prices at Dicks is quite high when I was there. With the Walmart expansion, Dicks in Platteville will go belly-up and take that plaza along with it.
Do they still have that 'Dick's Insider Card'? Awhile back, a young lady asks me to sign a petition against the card. I didn't understand what the fuss was all about and told her that the card offered some savings. She then said to think about it, "Dick's Insider Card.. Think. It's degrading to women." I gave her a confused look and signed it. Later when I got home it clicked, and I laughed real hard.
Anyway, people who visited me when I was there have a laugh about the only supermarket in town and it's called Dick's.
Posted by: Ex Student at May 14, 2005 9:08 PMI just lost my job at Dick's and I have Walmart to thank. They put so much pressure on Dick's to stay competitive that the workers were continually cut on hours and pay raises including the management. Some of our best left for greener pastures and that caused a trickle down effect on the rest of the workers there. All I can say is that Walmart is only nice and smiling on you if you shop there, you are going to get hurt if you have a job that is in competition with them. I have been out there and the parking lot is full, where are all the cars from, probably all over, spending their money somewhere else than on a better paying employers somewhere else, enjoy your cocaine/walmart folks, just don't complain when your nose starts bleeding.
Posted by: mark hatfield at April 21, 2006 2:03 PM